As a studio, we see the pursuit of climate justice, action against the mass extinction of species, and the strengthening of community resilience as the defining paradigm for society over the next hundred years. We are convinced that these concerns now fundamentally shape everything we do—how we eat and drink, dress, live, work, make music, and sing. We see an increasingly diverse repertoire of action gathering momentum on this ground.
(Movements to protect the commons / the erosion of the rural–urban divide / localisation within global networks / growing cooperatives / children formally going on school strike / the degrowth movement / climate change entering mainstream media / the economic costs of climate breakdown being laid bare.)
In architecture, every actor in the field—architects, practices, schools of architecture, and material manufacturers—is engaging with these questions. In light of these developments, we increasingly feel the need to reformulate our own work through this paradigm. Three headings are emerging. Our work and research in these areas have been intensifying for some time.
Across many different fields, a formula has already emerged—from fashion and food to biennials. At the risk of reducing it to a slogan, we use it as a basis from which to define the framework of our practice.
Nothing is this simple—or perhaps it is. Simply: simplicity.
I would like to note that we will later have the opportunity to expand on and examine separately the three headings of the formula through which we have set out to apply this paradigm shift to our own practice. This is the opening statement.
Not Consuming
Restoration / Renovation / Refurbishment / Transformation in Situ
Questioning whether anything new is needed at all, and using the tools of design to discover the ever-present potential of what already exists—what has already taken form.
Preferring What Can Be Transformed and Reused; Touching the Ground with Care; Becoming Lighter
Demountable Structures / Modular Planning / Lightweight Construction / Parametric Design
These approaches expand the spectrum of what is possible—offering, idealistically speaking, endless possibilities. They touch the ground—literally soil, water, slopes, and terrain—with care, yet can shift to other sites or functions when needed, or when no longer needed. In fact, they have always been there; we are simply producing and discovering them anew.
If You Must Consume, Choose the Option with the Least Environmental Impact
Biodegradable Building Materials — Timber Construction / Straw / Earth Structures / New Technologies
(Earth to earth, ashes to ashes.)
Collectively, we have accumulated extensive knowledge of these ancient technologies, to which we add our more recent discoveries: mycelium-based building materials, façade cladding made from algae, structures created by insects, and edible structures.
Until we reach a technological threshold at which artificial intelligence can model the entire system as it exists at a given moment, we cannot fully foresee the consequences of everything we do. When we began using fossil fuels, it was hardly possible to predict that we would one day create an effect capable of changing the climate by our own hand. We are only grasping this 150 years later, after causing countless tragedies.
It is clear that, even in using renewable resources, we must stay alert to unforeseen consequences and review each step again and again. We will make mistakes. The paths we choose may again prove wrong or dangerous. We may once again create problems we cannot undo. But with the benefit of this experience, we will identify them more quickly—and perhaps act more quickly too.
Now, if we return to the beginning, we ask our question again.
As a studio, our fundamental question—and our fundamental problem—among everything that must or could be done is not What? but Why? and How? (Without being cheesy.)
For a long time, after all, we grounded ourselves in aesthetics (!), in topography (?). Plain and quiet spaces, structures, and experiences. We gravitated towards Zumthor, Campo Baeza, Siza, Pawson, Ando, and that entire tradition. Now we are trying, once again, to construct our own story. We are searching for a language. Every new configuration produces a new language—one that cannot be translated or converted (with respect to Benjamin!).
Our field of play now is the search, within the territory defined above and with an affinity for the architects just mentioned, for methods of producing something similar yet fundamentally different—something that ultimately carries a powerful sense of place and space.
How can a sense and structure of place be created for the temporary? Can the movement found in the colour and texture of timber, as a building material, give rise to a Church of the Light?
This question—this problem—which is exactly what we are looking for, seems to us to open the door to efficiency in design:
“We must use tools A/B/C—the theoretical plane, conceptual framework, and so on—constraint 1: vital and compelling—to arrive at results of type X/Y/Z—constraint 2: arbitrary, contrived, elitist, hysterical.”
And as we work through our own thinking processes, over and over, we also witness climate change being instrumentalised as a way of muddying the waters around efficiency in design. Architecture and design exploit other fields to serve their own interests and assert their existence. We cannot escape this ontological question—this problem. We have identified it and left it where it is. Now we work from here.
Note: As long as we find the story capable of formulation—as long as we try to formulate it—is the paradigm really changing? Or are we merely dealing with different variables? We are inside this structure of thought; imagining its outside is impossible. If the underlying structure can change only through synapses that suddenly emerge and mutations that accumulate until they reach a critical point… then let us celebrate our mistakes.
Oznur Caglayan
